Related
Summary
The late Leonard Nimoy hatedStar Trek Generations , the first film star the cast ofStar Trek : The Next contemporaries . Nimoy not only portrayed the Vulcan Mr. Spock inStar Trek : The Original Series , but he develop into one of the franchise ’s most celebrated directors after helmingStar Trek III : The Search For SpockandStar Trek IV : The Voyage Home , which was the most financially successful movie starringStar Trek ’s original cast . Naturally , Nimoy was Paramount ’s first option to directStar Trek Generations , a job he turned down flat and ultimately went to director David Carson .
Star Trek Generations was conceived as thecast ofStar Trek : The Next Generation ’s jumping to the big screen and the qualifying of the torch byTheOriginal Seriescrew . Paramount wanted a team - up moving-picture show where the classicStar Trekactors would appear in the origin before Captain James T. Kirk ( William Shatner ) teamed up withTNG ’s Captain Jean - Luc Picard ( Patrick Stewart ) in the concluding act , which would end with Kirk ’s death . However , most ofStar Trek : The Original Series ' player turned down what they felt were glorify cameos , including DeForest Kelly and Nimoy . TheTOSholdouts believe appearing inGenerationswould besmirch how they graciously bow out withStar Trek VI : The Undiscovered Country .
Only William Shatner , James Doohan as Scotty , and Walter Koenig as Chekov signed ontoStar Trek Generations .
Star Trek Generations not only passed the torch to the form of The Next Generation , it also reveal the ultimate circumstances of Captain James T. Kirk .
The Reasons Leonard Nimoy Hated Star Trek Generations
Was Nimoy right about Star Trek VII?
TheStar Trekoral history , The Fifty - Year Mission : The Next 25 Yearsby Mark A. Altman and Edward Gross , honestly revealed the behind - the - conniption agitation involving Leonard Nimoy ’s frigid response toStar Trek Generations . Nimoy ’s beef withStar Trek Generationswas about its story and characterization . Nimoy comparedGenerationstoWilliam Shatner ’s problematic directorial debut , Star Trek pentad : The Final Frontier , which he favor :
Bill ’s picture … had its own built - in problems … which he was never die to be able to surmount . But generation bothered me . My God , what are they doing ? Why that prospect ? What ’s this scene about ? Where are they going with this ? That was the reason I was n’t involved in take in it .
In addition , Nimoy was appall at the way Spock was written in his intended cameo :
There was a character reference called Spock who had a dozen note you could easily assign to anyone else , which they did .
Nimoy also sawStar Trek Generationsasless of a genuine celluloid and more as a selling gimmickby Paramount :
Star Trek seven was a media event . Generations … two senior pilot run across at the Nexus . Okay . Something to sell . And they sell very severely on it … But I do n’t think the picture was very good … My feeling about Generations is very negative .
Leonard Nimoy ’s Star Trek Movie Appearances
yr
Role
Star Trek : The Motion Picture
1979
Actor
Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan
1982
Star Trek III : The Search For Spock
1984
Director , Actor
Star Trek IV : The Voyage nursing home
1986
Director , Actor , Story
Star Trek fin : The Final Frontier
1989
Star Trek VI : The Undiscovered Country
1991
Actor , Executive Producer , Story
Star Trek
2009
Star Trek Into Darkness
2013
Star Trek Generations Producers Agree With Leonard Nimoy’s Issues
Although Rick Berman and Leonard Nimoy had a falling out over Star Trek Generations
Leonard Nimoy ’s anger part stemmed from the fact that , as the intended director , he was n’t allowed to rewriteStar Trek Generations ' screenplay to address his issue . Executive manufacturer Rick Berman and atomic number 27 - writers Ronald D. Moore and Brannon Braga collaborate onStar Trek Generations ' hand . Paramount"loved it"because the writers fulfilled Paramount ’s many edict as to what call for to be in the moving-picture show . Only then was it bestow to Nimoy , who was not proud of with what he register . Berman return :
When Leonard interpret it , he say , ' This needs a Sir Frederick Handley Page - one rewrite ' . I told him [ no ] … and we parted ways … It was unusual for us to write a script with no director involved at all . Mr. Nimoy is ripe that he likely should have had a toss at the hand .
Berman and Nimoy had a falling out over Leonard ’s refusal to directStar Trek Generations . As Brannon Braga tells it , " They never spoke again . They were both p*ssed at each other . “Braga , who has his ownregrets about howStar Trek Generationsturned out , recall :
[ The ] film director … was ab initio Leonard Nimoy … Nimoy learn the playscript and hated it and feel [ the only interesting part ] of the hand wasData ’s emotion chip tale . By the way , he in all likelihood was n’t wrong .
Leonard Nimoy Returned To Star Trek 15 Years After Generations… For J.J. Abrams
Nimoy reprised Spock in Star Trek (2009) and Star Trek Into Darkness
15 eld afterStar Trek Generations , a newStar Trekmovie starred Leonard Nimoy and had his all over blessing . Nimoy recapitulate Spock in J.J. Abrams’Star Trek(2009 ) reboot film . Leonard ’s original version of Spock , dub Spock Prime , not only met the vernal alternative world Benjamin Spock played by Zachary Quinto and Captain James T. Kirk play by Chris Pine , but the Hellenic Vulcan was integral to the creation of the alternate Kelvin timeline stage setting of J.J. Abrams ' Star Trek moving-picture show trilogy . Nimoy talk effusively of Abrams’Star Trek , andLeonard changed his approach to playing Ambassador Spock .
Leonard Nimoy ’s intuitive feeling about J.J. Abrams ' Star Trek were the opposite of his scorn for Star Trek Generations .
Nimoy played Spock Prime one final sentence inStar Trek Into Darkness . Leonard was supposed to seem inStar Trek Beyondas well but he pass off in February 2015.Star Trek Beyondrevealed that Ambassador Spock conk on New Vulcan , and the film was give to the previous Leonard Nimoy and to Anton Yelchin , who also tragically died in 2016 . Leonard Nimoy ’s feelings about J.J. Abrams ' Star Trek were the opposite of his disdain forStar Trek Generations . in the end , Leonard Nimoy was correct that Spock had no tangible character to play inStar Trek Generations , butaudiences will never know if Nimoy could have improved the film if he were able-bodied to rewrite and aim it .
Star Trek Generationsis available to stream on Max .
Source : reference : The Fifty - Year Mission : The Next 25 Years : From The Next Generation to J. J. Abrams : The Complete , Uncensored , and Unauthorized unwritten account of Star Trekby Mark A. Altman and Edward Gross
