Related
Summary
When it comes toThe Hobbitbook vs movie there are many noted differences , and some are quite surprising . When Peter Jackson announced that he ’d be directing a trilogy base on J. R. R. Tolkien’sLord of the Ringsprequel , The Hobbit , the response was one of fervour . However , the trilogy depart some devotee of the account book were confused , sacrifice how little the amount of reservoir material was useable to flesh out such an challenging task . In his transformation of the book into a trilogy of handsome - budget Hollywood action at law blockbuster , Jackson took many originative autonomy .
This inescapably think of that the difference betweenThe Hobbitbook and movies were perfect . Jackson follow up changes galore , adding in plenty of raw capacity which was loosely adapt from Tolkien ’s other deeds . Some of it impinge on the mark , while the rest felt like extra makeweight . There ’s no enquiry that in the case ofThe Hobbitbook vs picture show , Jackson did his best to please interview . However , there were a few modification that many sports fan did n’t palpate fit the storey at all , construct it seem like Jackson was trying to addextraneous connecter toLOTRto take advantage on its success .
variety to Tolkien canyon are often knock , but some of the adjustment made for Peter Jackson ’s Lord of the Rings trilogy made the story better .
25The Romance Between Tauriel And Kílí
Tolkien Never Envisioned A Dwarf And An Elf Falling In Love
Of all the characters inThe Hobbitmovie trilogy who were n’t in Tolkien ’s novel , Tauriel is the one who requires the most investigating when talk about differences between the book and Peter Jackson ’s films . She ’s an original character created specifically for the screen , so represent one of the most controversial changes for Tolkien purist . However , in addition to her presence in general , a pigboat - plot of ground for the character is also a huge deviation from Tolkien ’s Middle - earth — the romance between Tauriel and Kílí .
A romantic relationship between an elf and a midget is a notable difference from any of Tolkien ’s books , regardless of which character are involved . While it ’s true that inter - species romances are n’t unheard of ( with the relationship between the human Aragorn and elf Arwen inLord of the Ringsbeing a prime exemplar ) , Tolkien never spoke of a dwarf and elf becoming amorously entangled . While there ’s nothing to suggest he was against the idea , discover Kílí woo Tauriel throughout Jackson ’s movie trilogy was a distinct and celebrated change from the root fabric .
24The Final Battle With Smaug
There Was No Epic Showdown With The Dragon In The Novel
The face-off with Smaug inThe Hobbit : The Battle of the Five Armiesis one of the most epic sequences in Peter Jacksons movie trilogy . However , it ’s also a moment that happens almost completely otherwise in Tolkien ’s original novel . While Jackson hold several key particular about how Smaug decease , the moment is importantly elevated and filled with much more action than the death of the dragon in Tolkien ’s book .
In the book , just like inThe Battle of the Five Armies , Smaug is killed by an arrow shaft in the right spot of his stomach . However , Smaug in Tolkien ’s novel does n’t cause anywhere near as much destruction . What ’s more , Bard does n’t but get a favourable guesswork with his Black Arrow in the Christian Bible . In Tolkien ’s version , Bard learns of Smaug ’s light play after being told about it by a bird . While this is emphatically more whimsical , it also probably would n’t have fit the tone of Peter Jackson ’s movie trilogy .
23Azog The Defiler Was Only A Sidenote In The Books
Thorin’s Orc Rival Was Greatly Elevated
stretch out out Tolkien’sThe Hobbitnovel naturally think that Peter Jackson need to expand upon several characters when flesh out the tale . This was specially true when it came to the opposer , since having Bilbo ’s grouping spending over nine hours of screentime trying to spoil Smaug alone would likely have created pacing issues . It ’s this want that lead to one of the bragging deviation betweenThe Hobbitbooks and movies — the role of Azog the Defiler .
In Peter Jackson ’s movies , Azog is a fearful and fantastically dangerous Orc who has a long - suffer rivalry with Thorin . He is encountered multiple times by Bilbo ’s grouping , and on many occasions very about brings their quest to an abrupt and previous conclusion . While Azog is an important name in Tolkien ’s reading of halfway - worldly concern , he ’s nowhere near as big a frame in the report ofThe Hobbit . Having Azog as a principal opponent was a creative decision made by Peter Jackson , though it ’s arguably one that improved his flick trilogy importantly .
22Multiple Battles With The Orcs
Tolkien’s Version Of The Story Was Far Less Violent
Azog the Defiler is n’t the only orc to appear much more frequently in Peter Jackson’sThe Hobbitmovies than in Tolkien ’s novel . broadly talk , there are many more battles against orcs in the on - screen version of the narration than there are in the Bible . InThe Hobbitmovies , there are skirmishes against orcs when Bilbo ’s group are on the way to Rivendell , get away from the extremely low frequency , and in Lake Town , to name a few examples . None of these conflict with orcs take place in Tolkien’sThe Hobbitnovel .
However , there is a unproblematic explanation for this difference betweenThe Hobbitbooks and motion picture , and why it was a near originative determination on Peter Jackson ’s part . The Hobbitmovie trilogy is framed much more directly as a prequel toThe Lord of the Rings . This is attest by , for model , the comportment of characters like Frodo or Legolas . However , it also meant a tonal shift was postulate .
LotRis a history that focuses much more intemperately on war and conflict in Middle - globe , whereas Tolkien ’s novel is more of a whimsical escapade . Including more battles against orcs is a insidious conflict , and one that sceptic have suggested was made to pad out the runtime of the trilogy . However , it really facilitate Jackon’sThe Hobbitmovies have more in common withThe Lord of the Ringsmovies .
21Bilbo And The Dwarves Spent Weeks In Mirkwood
Time In The Forest Took Up Much Of Their Journey
InThe Hobbit : The Desolation of Smaug , Bilbo and his radical takea roundabout way through Mirkwoodon their elbow room to the Lonely Mountain . This roundabout way is intended as a shortcut , shortening the duration of their journeying significantly . However , while Peter Jackson ’s film make it seem like Bilbo and the Dwarves spent very little time in the legendary forest , the same is n’t truthful in Tolkien’sThe Hobbitnovel .
InThe Hobbitbook , Bilbo , Thorin , and the rest of the dwarfs spend what ’s implied to be as long as several hebdomad in the wood . They have many small adventures there , and it ’s an improbably significant part of the overall quest for Bilbo . There were several tense moments in Mirkwood in the leger too , such as when the group run out of nutrient .
While cut this part of the level down does make some sense for Peter Jackson’sThe Hobbittrilogy , it ’s also one of the more confusing differences between the book and the movies . There ’s a strong contestation that the director could have include several significant Mirkwood moments from Tolkien ’s news report .
20Gandalf’s Reason For Seeking Out Bilbo
The Gandalf Of The Novel Never Met Child Bilbo
Gandalf ’s reason for finding Bilbo are dissimilar when take care atThe Hobbitbook vs movie . Inthe novelisation ofThe Hobbit , it is established thatGandalf seeks out Bilbo for the quest , in particular because of a memory board he had of his mother . According to Gandalf , he was impressed by Belladonna Took , because of her adventuresome emotional state and personality , and he hoped that side would get along out if Bilbo joined them on an adventure .
In the film , Gandalf reminisce about experience Bilbo as a new boy , who adored the mentation of danger , excitement , and escapade . The modification is n’t a huge one , but it does say a mountain about Bilbo ’s character as he appeared in the book , versus the film adaptation . Either way , it ’s an opportunity forGandalf to deliver one of his best lines of the trilogy .
19The Dwarven Contract
Peter Jackson Made The Paperwork Longer For Comic Effect
Another one of the boastful differences betweenThe Hobbitbook and movie is the dwarven contract . The dwarves play a central role in bothThe Hobbitmovies and the original record book , with the front of the raceway as a whole far keen than it was inLord of the Rings . In fact , it ’s partially due to a contract with the midget that Bilbo lead the shire in the first seat . The details of the dwarven contract with Bilbo Baggins are never explicitly fix , which is why it ’s so comical to see the moving-picture show version go on everlastingly when unrolled .
It was Jackson ’s way of inject some comedy into the film , peculiarly at such an early start to the story .
It was Jackson ’s way of shoot some drollery into the cinema , especially at such an early start to the level . In the Word of God , the contract is a simple note impart on his blanket , with two short paragraphs acting as content . That ’s a stark direct contrast to the picture version , and one of the few changes Jackson made that actually aid make the story better .
18Bilbo Leaving Bag-End
In Peter Jackson’s Version Of The Tale Hobbits Never Travel Light
Even the agency that Bilbo leaves Bag - End contrasts in the case ofThe Hobbitbook vs movie . This alteration was small , but noticeable , and it occur when Bilbo finally decides to make a go of it and join the dwarf on their adventure . In the flick , he races after them with a haversack full of stuff and catches up with them before they get too far down the route . In the book , however , it is said that Bilbo give Bag - End without even a handkerchief in his pouch .
In truth , Jackson ’s variety was probably for the best , as any Hobbit would never escape off without a few of the comforts of home . It ’s established in theLord of the Ringsmovies that Hobbits enjoy their creature comforts , with the likes of Samwise Gamgee bemoan his of any nutrient other than Lambas bread even while in sedate danger , and Pippin insist on 2nd breakfast . With this context in the cinematic enfranchisement , it prepare much more sense that Bilbo left The shire horse well - prepared .
17Knowledge Of The Necromancer
Gandalf Already Knew About The Antagonist In The Book
Sauron is a mystery to those who only watched the movies , but changing Gandalf ’s knowledge of the Necromancer arguably broke canyon when it come toThe Hobbitbook vs picture . InThe Hobbitfilms , Gandalf learns of the Necromancer when he speak to Radagast , which is what Peter Jackson used as the reason for Gandalf leaving Thorin and company .
This change was probably made to ensure audiences were n’t recede along the way as the story blossom forth .
However , in the Holy Writ , Gandalf is already well aware of the Necromancer . In J.R.R Tolkien ’s version ofThe Hobbit , Gandalf has already visited Dol Guldur , and heard of the Necromancer , as it was there that he find Thráin , the Fatherhood of Thorin Oakenshield , and received the mathematical function and keystone that he later gives to Thorin . This change was likely made to ensure hearing were n’t lost along the way as the account unfolded , as having to flashback to Gandalf ’s goings - on prior to the events ofThe Hobbitwould have required even more screentime in an already lengthy trilogy .
16Dwalin’s Beard
A Subtle Yet Noticable Aesthetic Difference
Though it was not a monumental modification that bear on the plot , there was one component of Dwalin ’s appearance that sort as one of the differences betweenThe Hobbitbook and movie . Interestingly enough , the book says , " It was a dwarf with a blue beard tucked into a golden belt , and very bright eyes under his dark - unripe hood . “This is a thoroughgoing change from how Dwalin is designate in the movie , with a brunette byssus and non-white centre .
While some reader have argued over the ages that it was n’t meant to literally be grim , others believe Dwalin ’s beard really was meant to be that way , so as to seem " otherworldly . " When the script was written for theHobbitfilm , Jackson choose to take out a lot of the whimsy to make it more in line withThe Lord of the Rings , mean Dwalin ’s blue beard was one of the first things to go .
