The Boys
monition ! SPOILERS forThe BoysSeasons 1 - 3 and the cartoon strip ahead . Black Noirnever speaks or removes his mask inThe Boyswhether on page or screen , but the reasonableness Black Noir stick around masked are different in the comic and the who . In Garth Ennis’The Boysgraphic novel Black Noir has a very unlike backstory to the Black Noir of the show , but both share a few characteristics — the principal one being that neither removes their mask . While both end up record their true face at various point in their respective floor , it ’s a disgraceful reveal when they do , although for completely different understanding . Here ’s why Black Noir never removes his mask inThe Boys , why he never speak , and why inThe Boyscomicsit ’s a choice , but in the show , it ’s really not .
When the news that Supes are made , not born , broke inThe Boysseason 2 , the Supes react in dissimilar way of life . Despite appear distraught over the news about Compound V and the cognition that he was an experiment who was rob of a normal childhood , Black Noir on the face of it occupy it upon himself to hunt down the individual creditworthy for The Seven ’s recent bad luck : Billy Butcher . During the undermentioned encounter , Black Noir start a phone call from Mr. Edgar , revealing he was acting under the order of the company ’s chief operating officer the whole meter . What ’s interesting is that when Black Noir got the phone call , he did n’t speak – in fact , he has n’t speak at all since his introduction inThe Boysseason 1 . This is something he shares with his comic book similitude , but the comic version eventuallydoesspeak . TheBlack Noir comics revealwas that he ’s a clone of Homelander and part of The Seven as a failsafe in case Homelander ever got out of control condition . Not address and being fully covered up is merely a way of concealing his identity element .
relate : The Boys : Why Black Noir ’s Comic Reveal Wo n’t pass In The TV Show
Conversely , inThe BoysAmazon serial publication , Black Noir is n’t opt to remain silent . Black Noir is n’t a Homelander clone inThe Boys -he ’s a " regular " Supe and part of Soldier Boy ’s original ' fourscore superhero squad Payback . During Payback ’s engagement against Soldier Boy , Black Noir received catastrophic mentality injury that left him both unable to verbally communicate and saddled with bizarre delusion of toon animals . Soldier Boy ’s rage also left Noir with significant scarring , which is why the Amazon Prime iteration ofThe Boys’Supekeeps their side embrace . The comic Christian Bible Black Noir has to , lest he reveals his clone identity , but the Black Noir ofThe Boysshow has much more tragic reason for keeping schtum . Here ’s everything you require to make love about why Black Noir does n’t speak or take off his mask inThe Boys .
The Comic And TV Black Noirs Are Very Different Characters
fan who started readingThe Boysafter watching the show often palpate surprised at how much has change . The Boysis based on the original Garth Ennis knead , but it ’s far from a lineal adaptation . Everything from character backstories to the overarching plot has been alter , and by the end ofThe Boysseason 1 , it was clear Amazon ’s show was moving in its own direction , with the event of time of year 2 and season 3 examine any predictions based on the comics were pretty much disputable . Perhaps no character illustrates the difference of opinion between thetwo versions ofThe Boysbetter than Black Noir . In both , he is a unsounded , masked antagonist , and their look is reasonably like , but these are perhaps the only mutual threads between them .
InThe Boyscomics , Black Noir is revealed to be the brain behind a lot of events . He ’s a clone of Homelander and intensely acrid about his lot in life . Because Black Noir did n’t mouth for so long and was forced to live in solitude , he developed an intense hatred for Homelander . He wanted to bring down Vought ’s crown jewel whether they wanted him to or not , so he outrage Becca Butcher and take pictures to frame Homelander . This is patently very dissimilar from the show , wherein Homelander raped Becca himself and continued to torment her long after she carried their child to full term . Thecomic Becca Butcher diedwhen the tiptop - powered foetus claw its way out of her ( this was also the incident that lay Billy Butcher on his path ) . The risible - book Black Noir has to remain voiceless and faceless to conceal their identicalness as a Homelander knockoff , and their resentment over this is a cardinal secret plan point inThe Boys’graphic novel narrative . The Black Noir inThe Boyshas a much less plot - centrical role and all different reason for never speak or depict their face . Black Noir is n’t a Homelander clone in the show . He ’s an African American Supe known only as Earving who ’d been operating for decades prior toThe Boysseason 1 .
A appendage of both The Seven andSoldier Boy ’s team Payback , Black Noir did n’t speak in the show either , but this had nothing to do with concealing his identity . As revealed in a season 3 flashback ( or to be more appropriate , a dramatization of Black Noir ’s life narrate by his hallucinated cartoon beast companions ) , Black Noir suffered extensive brain damage at the hands of Soldier Boy . This flashback is also the only time Black Noir ’s voice is heard post - accident , but from the lips of a cartoon sheep he ’s ideate . By the time Homelander and The Seven arrived inThe Boyspre - show canyon , Black Noir was several tenner into his life as Vought ’s faceless voiceless assassinator . The personalities of the two Noir versions are wildly diverging . The alive - activeness Black Noir appears to have an almost childlike emotional range at points , such as when he sobs like a scorned toddler upon learning thetruth of Compound V. The sadistic Homelander clone is nothing like the damaged - and - relatable nameless Black Noir of the show . element of the funny - book Black Noir made their way intoThe Boyson Amazon but mostly as part of Homelander ’s backstory ( for example , the trauma from growing up as a lab task come flat from the Ennis ' version of Black Noir ) .
Related : The Boys ' Black Noir Twist Went Further Than The MCU Ever Dared
Comic Book Black Noir Doesn’t Talk – TV Show Black Noir Can’t
Black Noir ’s real expression is demonstrate during a flashback inThe Boysseason 3 , episode 3 ( play by Fritzy Klevans - Destine rather than Nathan Mitchell ) . This scene give viewers a glimpse of the pre - brain - price Black Noir , showing his struggle to be visible on the team , dump his earmark masquerade , and move from Soldier Boy ’s shadow . This confirmed to TV audience that Black Noir had n’t always been the silent , masked holy terror view inThe Boysseasons 1 and 2 . However , despite the fact thatSoldier Boy ’s assaultrobbed Noir of both his voice and the confidence to remove his masquerade around others , he still non - verbally communicates with others . There are multiple examples of this inThe boy , but the most poignant comes right before Black Noir ’s death in the season 3 finale .
Homelander face Black Noir about Soldier Boy . unidentified to Noir , Homelander has learned that Soldier Boy is his Fatherhood . Noir test to admonish Homelander about Soldier Boy , writing out words in declamatory blocking letters with a permanent marking on tabloid - sized sheets of paper . The words he uses is simple though , and he ’s only able to indite one - word solution like " BAD " . As unwrap by the conversations of his cartoon role and in the flashback , however , Black Noir is fantastically articulated . The brain scathe he digest at the hands of thepowerful Solder Boyimpacted his power to babble out , but his agreement of language is integral . His emotions are a unlike story , however . The trauma of his experience has render Black Noir an undisputed psychopath . Even though his backstory make his character easy to commiserate with , he ’s still a mass murderer with the blood of inexperienced person on his mitt . However , he ’s a far cry from the sky-high sadistic Homelander , and miles aside from the sociopathic Homelander cloneBlack NoirofThe Boyscomics . Both are masked and mostly silent , but the men beneath those masquerade party could n’t be more different .
