The Boys
Could Homelander ’s son takeBlack Noir ’s comic playscript role inThe Boys ? From Stormfront to Soldier Boy , The Boyshas introduced a generous serving of horrifying raw supes over its last few seasons , but the surprisal package is Ryan Butcher , the Logos of Homelander and Becca Butcher . Given how morally missing Homelander is and Ryan ’s minacious flushed eyes inThe Boys ' season 1 last , viewer were incertain what to anticipate from the character in season 2 and beyond . Instead of following in his father ’s footsteps , however , Ryan turn out to be a odorous kid making home moving-picture show with LEGO and enjoying his schoolhouse piece of work . But Ryan also killed his female parent ( accidentally ) and now seems to be coordinate purposefully with Homelander heading intoThe Boysseason 4 .
Amazon’sThe Boyshas roughly followed the comic books by Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson , but the show does n’t seem to be heading towards the original ending . In the comic strip , Black Noir is revealed to be a clone of Homelander , make by Vought as a contingence program in face their top supe ever misplace control . The later issues show that Black Noir was behind most of Homelander ’s crimes from the very beginning , including the rape of Becca , and The Boys make a striking final standpoint against the unmasked Noir . In the show , however , during the ill-famed " Almond Joy " scene , The Boysconfirmed that Noir was actually black , which rule out his Homelander clone tress . Season 3 gave even more insight into the type , whose literal name was Earving , before Homelander finally killed him off .
Related : The Boys Season 4 Cast Update Supports Worrying Ryan Villain Theory
However , The Boys ' season 2 and 3 finales tease howBlack Noir ’s role in the comicscould be satiate by Ryan Butcher in the TV serial . During Billy Butcher ’s tense luncheon with Stan Edgar in season 2 , the pair acknowledge Ryan as the only potential weapon system the world could swear on if Homelander ever locomote off the rails altogether . Ryan ’s office suggest as much too , since his optical maser power could maim Stormfront where Homelander ’s could n’t . But Ryan is n’t just a failsafe any longer ; the time of year 3 conclusion seems to imply that he ’s capable of committing or at least approving of heinous acts just like his father , which would also make him very similar to the comic ' Black Noir .
Why Ryan Is More Like The Comic Book Black Noir Than Black Noir
Where Black Noir was the anti - Homelander weapon inThe Boys ' original funny serial , Ryan Butcher is serving that persona in live - action , which have sense , as Becca ’s son died during childbirth in the source material . Replacing Homelander ’s clone withHomelander ’s Word inThe Boysshow feels like an appropriate change to Ennis ' account , but does this mean Ryan could take the same villainous path?The Boyshas repeatedly drive home how Homelander ’s unloving childhood turned him into a scoundrel . This is something Becca was deeply afraid of , and one of the main reasons she was desperate to keep her Word closelipped by . But Ryan then find himself at the mercy of the U.S. care system , and while Mallory did her best to ensure his condom , Ryan ’s rocky family relationship with Butcher duringThe Boysseason 3 has clearly take a toll on his emotional eudaemonia .
In the comic books , Black Noir became unstable because he was sick of wait for the decree tokill Homelanderand take up matter into his own manus . Instead , Ryan could be deprave by his unruly emotions and a healthy dose of PTSD . The result would be the same - a very angry , very powerful supe going on a rampage . An out - of - control Ryan would be a fun twist in the ongoing saga of Billy Butcher . Having previously been a consecrated hater of all supes , Butcher overcame his rage inThe Boysseason 2 and 3 and accepted Ryan , defending him from Homelander and later pushing him away on design to keep him safe .
The Boys Killed The Black Noir Homelander Clone Twist To Set Up Its Ryan One
The twisting that Black Noir has always been a Homelander clone and is in some ways more terrifying than Homelander himself is a large moment in the comics . The show ’s conclusion to go in a completely unlike direction with Noir still return some good stuff , offering a glimpse of Vought ’s twisted past times and create another sympatheticmember of The Seven . But killing off Black Noir and the clone twist left a gaping hole in Homelander ’s floor – one that the writers were probably always intending to occupy with Ryan . Evil Ryan could very well be coming inThe Boysseason 4 if his smirk at the close of the season 3 finale is any indicant . Aspects of the funnies ' Black Noir have been diluted into other characters and Homelander himself , so the tariff of being a failsafe who cease up an even more twisted version of Homelander could still devolve to Ryan . This would make for its own great turn and will certainly take a heavy toll on Butcher , pretend for a better - relate vane of motivations than the Butcher / Homelander dynamic in the comic .
Join Amazon Prime - Watch Thousands of Movies & TV Shows Anytime
protrude Free Trial Now
