Related
ThePercy Jackson and the Olympiansbooks are a globally loved phantasy serial with a innovative wrench on Greek Mythology , with a fandom similar to that ofHarry PotterandThe Hunger Games . However , unlike the latter book serial , The Lightning Thiefmovie and Percy Jackson ’s other movie adaptations ( of which there was only one despite there being five books and multiple spin - offs ) were double-dyed failure in the eyes of the fan . The source ofPercy Jacksonand other serial like theKane Chronicles , Rick Riordan , has himself spoken out about how severely adapted the books were . Likewise , even thePercy Jacksonmovie star Logan Lerman has said on multiple occasions that the books merit a better adjustment than the one given by the movie .
await at thePercy Jacksonmovie and the lack of attention to point display in the plot of ground , it ’s graspable that fans were and still are very frustrated at the way the big - screen adaption flex out . When aPercy Jackson and the OlympiansTV series was harbinger for Disney+ , fans were immediately tentative but were assure to determine that Riordan would be involved , unlike withThe Lightning Thiefmovie . With the newPercy Jacksonshow being actively in the works , now is a good clip to look back on thePercy Jacksonmoviesin order to explicate why exactly the author , actors , and fans could n’t have perchance appreciated it .
relate : Hunger Games : Every Major Difference Between The Movies & Bible
The Percy Jackson Movies Rushed The Characters' Stories
Character alteration are n’t always uncollectible , but Percy and other lineament being 11 or 12 geezerhood honest-to-god at the start of the book was an of import part of their taradiddle . By contrast , The Lightning Thiefmovie made the age divergence between Percy and Luke unseeable , removing the tenseness in many minute .12 - year - olds falling off a bridge or fighting gigantic monsters and face gods makes for more drama than teenagers ( who are almost adult ) doing the same . In addition to making the independent characters from the Holy Scripture quondam , the motion picture also changed core vista of their personality and their kinship to one another .
Since the character in thePercy Jacksonmoviewere 15 or 16 years old , Annabeth and Percy almost instantly develop romantic tension , whereas in the source stuff they scarcely wish each other as friend and take four rule book to begin take the feelings they have – even to themselves . This gradual build relieve oneself sense for children who grow into young adult , but because the movies start with Annabeth and Percy as teenagers , they jumped towards romance without really having earn it .
Character Changes Ruined Percy Jackson’s Biggest Reveals
The change made to Luke ’s character were particularly detrimental . In the film , he concede to being the bad bozo early in the second half , whereas the book had him come back in the last chapter , sending a monstrosity from blaze to poison Percy . Since Percy beats Luke before buzz off to Olympus in the movie , it altogether undermines Luke as a scoundrel , as audience already know that when push come to shove , Percy can beat the son ofHermes ( played by Nathan Fillion ) . In the original oeuvre , the first real confrontation between Percy and Luke as a villain is at the end of the second book . Percy barely have it out alive , and would n’t have survived if it was n’t for the chemical group of Centaurus that amount to his rescue .
Percy ’s changes also make him a less compelling character . A slew of the back talk that Percy displays in the books is taken away in thePercy Jacksonmovies ( to make him seem more mature , perhaps ) , and he ’s almost at once in full control of his powers inThe Lightning Thiefmovie , whereas it take away him years in the books to hold on just how powerful he is . Annabeth comes off as much more arrogant in theproblematicPercy Jacksonmovies . Grover is given a much magnanimous use and , in turn , come up off as much more confident than in the first book . This is n’t a negative trait to give a character , but Grover ’s sureness come progressively in the Holy Writ because his background and preceding failures have led to his timid nature .
Related : Perks of Being a Wallflower : The Movie ’s large Changes From The Book
Percy’s Quest In The Lightning Thief Is Worse
plot of land changes are a unwashed practice when it comes to adapting Quran into movies , but it should n’t imply rewriting the entire taradiddle . ThePercy Jacksonmovies did just that , incorporating monsters and storylines that did n’t come out until afterwards in the book serial . While changes are n’t always forged , they can be alienate to the movie ’s ramp up - in audience of exist fans . When hoi polloi saw themovie adaptation ofDuneorHarry ceramist , they gestate the core tarradiddle to stay intact and for the characters to be relatable in the same means that they were in the book , and were n’t disappointed . ThePercy Jacksonmovie ’s limiting to the plot were so extensive that they changed the characters ’ development , and not for the estimable .
In the movie , Percy needs to acquire three bone in lodge to get to the Underworld to confront Hades about Zeus ' stolen lightning dash . Percy , Annabeth , and Grover go looking for fuss because they anticipate to take the pearls from monsters . They have to pinch out of pack because Chiron forbids them to go look for Percy ’s mum - and the bolt of lightning . But in the books , the fact that Percy ’s mom is miss is what channelize him in his adventures . Chiron boost him to go on the pursuit , and Percy , who was only just made mindful ofMount Olympus and the world of Greek Gods , barely handle about the bolt . On his style to the Underworld , he unintentionally feed into a dyad of monster .
In the case ofThe Lightning Thiefmovie , the changes were n’t earned , and they made the story more confusing . On top of everything , the end of the movie does n’t make for a good changeover into the rest of the saga , whereas the book had the perfect way to stick in the relaxation of the series ’ independent plot of land . Because Percy was already a great warrior and had already defeated Luke once and had apparently wholly come into his power , not only did the motion-picture show provide devotee with a disappointing and inaccurate adaptation , it also put the residuum of the series on a washy footing , somethingWalker Scobell’sPercy Jacksonshowwill hopefully avoid in its first season .
The Sea of Monsters Unnecessarily Merges Two Percy Jackson Books
Because the firstPercy Jacksonmovie did n’t set up the rest of the serial right , the sequel , Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters , turn out rather confusing . The first scenery is very intense and start with a much older - looking Percy – Logan Lerman , who was already 18 in the first motion picture , was now 21 – fighting with a random Modern character who seemingly is his nemesis . In the books , Clarisse is a bully to Percy from the indorsement he engender to camp . That enables their rivalry to grow over the year and , in the second book of account of the series , make tension when the pursuit is specify to Clarisse , but Percy still decide to go .
link : How Each Twilight Movie References The Book Covers
On top of the lack of continuity , Sea of Monsterstotally changed the outcome of its book(s ) . In an odd inverse of how franchises likeTheHunger Gamesmade two movie for one book , The Sea of Monstersis a uniting of book two and five , causing a luck of confusion , a lot of secret plan cuts , and a narrative that feels unnecessarily rushed . In the Quran , Luke and an U. S. Army of wild demigods and monsters expend five years add back a Chronos that was trim down into pieces and thrown into Tartarus . In the movies , Luke manages to bring back Chronos at the ending ofSea of Monsters , and it takes Percy a little less than 10 second to destruct him . Not only is that anticlimactical for a fantasy adventure saga , it once again destruct the characters .
Part of the understanding it takes Chronos so long to come back in the books is that Percy is an obstacle every step of the agency . Luke — played in thePercy Jacksonmovies by Jake Abel ofMalignant , another box office failure — actually sacrifices his body for Chronos to possess , construct Percy and specially Annabeth waver when it come to kill him . This storyline enable Luke to find repurchase in the end . The movie ’s word picture of Chronos is a giant flack monstrosity that would be able-bodied to crush any of them under his metrical foot and create no moral dilemma for the main characters .
What Percy Jackson Got Right
There are so many things that went wrong with thePercy Jacksonmovie that it ’s unacceptable to name them all . However , as a movie , Percy Jackson and the Olympians : The Lightning Thiefwasn’t all bad . The CGI was pretty decent , and the storyline is serviceable . Moreover , The Lightning Thiefmovie had some successes , such as the casting ofJames Bond histrion Pierce Brosnanas Chiron and Steve Coogan as Hades . Even more generally , the movie helped introduce Greek mythology and thePercy Jacksonbooks themselves to a wider audience . At the closing of the day , though , The Lightning Thiefmovie was suppose to be a Word of God adaptation and owed at least some fidelity to the seed stuff . The script just took some aspects of the book , like the character name and the whimsy that the stories bring a mod twist to mythology , and ran with it – without doing the book serial any justice . Hopefully , the Disney+Percy Jackson and the Olympiansseries will be better both as an adaptation and a standalone story .
Why Disney Hasn’t Given Up On Percy Jackson
Two word excuse why Disney has n’t given up onthePercy Jacksonshow — franchise potential . The first of thePercy Jacksonbooks came out in 2005 and cumulate a strong pursual . While the young adult novel did n’t quite reach the fame of say , Harry PotterorThe Hunger Games , the creation ofPercy Jacksonattracted plenty of lector and garnered enough care to get their own feature film film . The relatable characters and intricate news report populace build up by author Rick Riordan capture lector across the ball , with his Westernization of Hellenic Hellenic myth taking the world by storm . The writer has won multiple Mark Twain Awards and Children ’s Choice Book Awards for his works of fabrication , testify that thePercy Jacksonseries has meritoriousness despite the failure of the moving picture . So , there ’s certainly enough fan interest to justify Disney ’s choice to bring the Half - rakehell Ubermensch back to the diminished screen .
Outside of universal pursuit , Disney recognizes that there is vast franchise potential with thesuccessfulPercy Jacksonseries . Ever since Warner Bros. snagged the right forHarry Potter , with the plan park almost shoot down at the Magic Kingdom , Disney has been trying to do anything and everything they can to elevate a worthy competitor . The mega studio apartment even need to set up challenger in - star sign , with thePercy Jacksonseries possibly rivaling that of their Marvel division . See , Percy Jacksonisn’t the only series that author Rick Riordan has under his belt . He also hasThe Kane Chronicles , Heroes of Olympus , The Trials of Apollo , andMagnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard , which explore the ancient myths of Greek , Roman , Egyptian , and Norse . With all of this depicted object , there ’s huge potential to create some in - house competition between thePercy Jacksonseries and the MCU . Therefore , it ’s highly probable thatPercy Jackson and the Olympiansis just the beginning .
Next : Disney ’s Percy Jackson Show Can Still stave off 1 Major Casting Mistake
