Related
Warning : Contains spoiler forOne - lick Manchapter 168 .
Why doesOne - Punch Manhave three freestanding manga serial publication , and which ones are consider canyon ? Like many anime , One - Punch Manis based on a manga , but the agency that the manga is deal is less conventional than other series , most notably from having three unlike versions . This is an account of how all of that works , including which manga is the best to read .
TheOne - Punch Manmanga first start in 2012 , illustrated by Yusuke Murata and written by ONE ofMob Psycho 100fame . The manga quickly rose in popularity thanks to its stellar artwork and campaign scenes , and the anime made it an even bigger name by further emphasizing those traits . What many people might be incognizant of , though , is thatMurata’sOne - Punch Manis a remaking of a webcomic by ONE of the same name , and the manga , itself , often go through multiple revisions before a fresh volume is publish .
Related : One - Punch Man hypothesis : Blast Is Connected To Saitama ’s powerfulness
It ’s very unusual for a manga to have three different versions , and this is an account for whyOne - Punch Mandoes . Every version of the manga has its own history behind its construction , and the ins and outs of it all are certainly worth make into . Here ’s a breakdown of the process behind each version of the manga , and it should helpOne - Punch Manreaders sympathise the differences and why they ’re necessary for theOne - Punch Manstory .
The Three Different One-Punch Man Manga Series, Explained
The firstOne - Punch Manmanga was a 2009 webcomic write and illustrate by ONE , who also both wrote and illustratedMob Psycho 100 . The most far-famed difference between the webcomic and the manga is that the webcomic ’s artistic production is incredibly crude and often look like crude doodles ; ONE would gradually improve his prowess over the years , but it would never fully transcend his simplistic stylings . Nevertheless , the funniness and ordered series of the fight scenes still allowed the webcomic to attract an audience , even if it was a small one .
Among the people who became buff of theOne - Punch Manwebcomic was Yusuke Murata , a mangaka notable for exemplify the football game mangaEyeshield 21 . Murata was such a big fan of the series that he asked ONE to collaborate with him on a remaking , which led to the manga that most people are familiar with . The manga is largely the same news report as the webcomic , but there are some original floor , and the Monster Association arc , which began inOne - Punch Manseason 2 , was greatly expanded to create more worldbuilding and flesh out the characters in cracking point than the webcomic did . All of that is coupled with Murata ’s implausibly lifelike art and stellar scene constitution , which quickly led to the manga becoming a monumental hit around the world .
The third version of the manga is probably the left over , in that it ’s essentially an alternating interlingual rendition of what had already been write in the manga . Every now and then , ONE and Murata would go back to an older chapter and alter what come about in it , either by add up supernumerary pages or by wholly reworking the story ; notable examples include extend the fight between Child Emperor and Phoenix Man and retconning Saitama ’s scrap withOne - Punch Man ’s Garouso the manga can have its own take on Awakened Garou . Sometimes , it ’s done to improve on a engagement that was in the beginning lack in quality ; other times , it makes a fight run along up better with the worldbuilding of either the webcomic or the manga . Whatever the display case , if a chapter becomes the subject of a rewrite , then the rewritten chapter should be take in as the authoritative edition .
Related : One - Punch Man Season 2 Ended At A Very Weird Place
Which One-Punch Man Manga Is Best?
Clearly , many fans will only wish to interpret one iteration of theOne - Punch Manmanga , so which version should they read ? In terms of content , nothing is missed out by choosing one version over another , as they all comply the same canonic story . The manga go even further in that regard with how much it vary from the original webcomic with its story and worldbuilding . follow by Yusuke Murata ’s unbelievable fine art , Murata and ONE’sOne - Punch Manis definitely worth reading . That being said , if someone could only read a single translation ofOne - Punch Man , then they should read the webcomic . While the webcomic ’s prowess does n’t equate to the manga ’s , its story is actually better than the one in the manga . While the manga spread out on the webcomic ’s story does work in some areas , it also has the essence of causing storey arcs to drag on for too long , particularly when chapters end up going through revision that force the story through an even more drawn - out progression .
The story in the manga also often overcomplicates itself when compared to the manga , almost to the dot of being an empty spectacle . A notorious example is howOne - Punch Man’sSaitamaused Garou ’s martial arts to travel back in time and break him from destroying the Earth , the mechanics of which were completely nonsensical . The manga ’s handling of sure characters is also a point against it at time , as the manga often discard the subtleties of the webcomic to be all blunt about its theme , which often makes them work less effectively than they originally did . Thanks to all of that , theOne - Punch Manwebcomic , with better handling of the character reference and a quicker , less - twist floor , is probably the just version ofOne - Punch Manto read .
How The One-Punch Man Manga Series Compares To The Anime
As with most anime , the differences between theOne - clout Manmanga and the Zanzibar copal are largely paltry . There are sometimes original aspect or extend fight scenes , but it mostly travel along the Yusuke Murata - illustrate manga to the letter of the alphabet . TheOne - Punch Mananimehas had a few OVAs filled with original contentedness , but besides that , there are n’t any major differences between the anime and the manga .
More : What To Expect From One - Punch Man Season 3
