Lost
Many believe " We Have To Go Back " was the show ’s polar twist but , in world , it ’s the " Not Penny ’s gravy holder " second that changedLostforever , get the death of Charlie and spinning the narration on its head . WhenLostfirst aired in 2004 , it was a show with a relatively strand premiss about a chemical group of survivor lose on an island after a plane smash . The remaining rider of Oceanic Flight 815 not only endured the wilderness of the island but many inexplicable occurrent — everything from smoke monsters to polar bears and mystical underground vault .
Losthad many twists and turns , but the " Not Penny ’s Boat " disclose in theLostseason 3 net was a true game - record changer . When it seemed that a deliverance boat might be close to the island , Charlie ( Dominic Monaghan ) adjust out to find a way of life to get a content to it . Charlie was a central character onLost , a recovered drug addict who drop in love with Claire ( Emilie de Raven).Charlie ’s sacrifice to get the message outfor deliverance was grand and tragical , and the " Not Penny ’s Boat " scene showed the futility of his sacrifice .
What “Not Penny’s Boat” Means
Charlie’s Final Message Was A Warning About Dangers To Come
The " Not Penny ’s Boat " vista number in the season 3 finale , and the season culminated withCharlie ’s tragic ( and shocking ) death . For three season , Lostexplored the mysteries of the island , include the Others , the hatch , the smoke monster , and more , but this critical vista change everything for the characters and for the series . In theLostseason 3 finis , " Through the Looking Glass,“Charlie judge to come to terms with his impendent death , which was anticipate by Desmond ( Henry Ian Cusick ) .
Time travel plays a important role in Lost , specially during the show ’s later seasons , but how exactly does it work in the ABC series ’ universe ?
When rescue becomes a possibility , the survivors taste to notice a way to meet a gravy holder in the arena . The boat supposedly belongs to Desmond ’s girl , Penny ( Sonya Walger ) , who has been searching for him for years . In edict to speak to Penny , Charlie has to go on a suicide mission and keep out down a sign jammer in the underwater Dharma station . After Charlie is successful , he manages to make physical contact with cent , who shock Charlie by state that the ship is n’t hers . When Desmond arrives , Charlie writes on his hand the Book , " Not Penny ’s Boat . "
Why “Not Penny’s Boat” Set Up The Rest Of Lost
The Reveal Split The Remaining Flight 815 Survivors
The scene culminated in Charlie ’s death , but this is n’t the extent of the impact of Charlie ’s parting message . After Desmond shared the scandalous news with everyone else , Lostwas never the same again after time of year 3 . It led to a dark turn in theLostseason 4 premiere that disunite the core group into two camps , one led by Jack ( Matthew Fox ) and one led by Locke ( Terry O’Quinn ) . Locke and the others believed that the people on the boat had no intention of rescuing them , while Jack ’s grouping was determined to leave no matter what .
All things take , " Not Penny ’s sauceboat " putLoston a dark , irreversible line .
It ’s a split that the quality never completely arrive back from , and this is something that ’s recognise at a later point in time inLost . The survivor inLosthad their own vox populi on what Charlie ’s message meant , with some choosing to ignore it , while others decided to mind Charlie ’s warning and avoid the boat . This split between the case after Charlie ’s " not Penny ’s gravy holder " messageled to keen level of conflict between the main grapheme , as they ’re more shared than ever on what to do next .
Lost was hailed as one of the best new TV show of the millennium when the serial publication debuted , but 19 year later , its many flaws are glaringly obvious .
This is also the moment that sets the stage for the tarradiddle that played out across the next three season and finallyends in theLostseries finale . The twist sets up the introduction of several new lineament who joinLostand makes Charles Widmore ( Alan Dale ) — the actual possessor of the gravy boat — a cardinal part of the storey , as his search for the island has unrelenting consequences for many of the main characters , particularly Ben ( Michael Emerson ) . All thing considered , " Not Penny ’s gravy holder " putLoston a dark , irreversible course .
Lost Mastered The Weekly TV Twist (But Not How To Pay Them Off)
The Lost Ending Was Incredibly Divisive
While theLostfinale was yet another dissentious manner to finish a popular television receiver show , the serial is arguably responsible for making the weekly TV twist — like " not Penny ’s boat " — a cultural phenomenon . That being say , it had a toilsome time make the twists pay off in the remnant . The stunner ofLostis that it created a newfangled clime for boob tube show , one that required a turn at the end of every episode to keep viewers pay heed until the next installment .
most every popular TV series follows that format to this day , such asGame of ThronesorThe Walking Dead . However , Lostwasn’t always of necessity known for paying off these weekly twists and turns , and this is proven by the show ’s lackluster finale . The " Not Penny ’s gravy boat " twist setLoston an alone newfangled path , effectively changing the show forever . However , twist like this were n’t enough to save the series ' highly divisive ending , which did n’t really pay off satisfyingly .
Lost ’s Other Biggest Twists
Lost is a mystery drama series created for TV that follows a group of survivors of a plane crash and tells its story between the past, present, and future via flashbacks. When Oceanic Airlines Flight 815 crashes and lands on a mysterious island in the pacific ocean, the castaways discover their new temporary home may have a mind of its own, as strange supernatural events keep them locked to the island. From an unknown black smoke creature to dangerous islanders, the passengers must work together to survive the island’s seemingly deadly intentions.
twirl
sequence
John Locke is paralyzed
Season 1 , Episode 4 , " Walkabout "
Ethan was n’t on the sheet
Season 1 , Episode 10 , " raise by Another "
Walt is taken
Season 1 , Episode 23 , " hegira "
Michael kill Ana Lucia and Libby
Season 2 , Episode 20 , " Two for the route "
“Not Penny’s Boat” Was The Most Emotional Sacrifice In Lost
Charlie’s Arc Remains One Of The Show’s Most Heroic
There werea lot of deaths inLost , but it was Charlie ’s sacrifice that was the most emotional of them all . Seeing Sun and Jin die together was heartbreaking . Sayid ’s slaying was horrifying , as one of the most popular character on the show . Jack ’s forfeit at the ending was also heartbreaking , but satisfying at the same time . With that tell , what bechance to Charlie was devastating for viewers and , as remark , it changed the character on the show . That is how excited his death was and how important the " Not Penny ’s Boat " scene was .
Charlie was struggling with substance abuse when he crash on the island . He had a stash of narcotic hidden away on the planer , and he could have preserve his downward spiral . However , he turned things around . He went cold turkey and get the best his addictions , and of course , he fell in love with Claire . Claire was significant when the plane crashed , and Charlie eventually became a pseudo - father figure .
However , Charlie also knew that something had to be done to save Claire , the babe , and his fresh friends . He went on the mission to judge to save everyone and died after realizing that it was not Penny ’s sauceboat , mean his death was fate , but it was still for nothing in the oddment — nothing but a heroic forfeit for one ofLost’sbest characters .
“Not Penny’s Boat” Vs. “We Have To Go Back”
Both Moments Elevated Lost As A Series
When seem at these two iconic moments fromLost , it is engrossing to see how each of them had massive impacts on the audience by doing something totally different . The " We have to go back " moment is a brilliant lesson of the show run on the expectations and knowledge of the consultation who has beenwatchingLostfrom the beginning . When they see flashbacks require Jack , nothing seems out of the ordinary and even his overwrought behavior is in keeping with some of the flashback moments the viewers have realise from him .
However , the moment Kate point up is a wonderful shock that recontextualizes everything that has hap in this episode . After a moment of debate the possible action that these two knew each other before the crash , the interview becomes cognizant that they are see issue after the character get off the island . It is a immense reveal that confirms a big exploitation to come , but it is made all the more intriguing by the fact that Jack feels leaving the island was a mistake . It is a arresting cliffhanger to end the season on .
While that moment left the interview puzzling about all the possibilities of what that could mean , the " Not Penny ’s gravy boat " moment hit the viewing audience with a flood of emotions . The joy of colligate with Penny is immediately followed by the apprehension of her confirm that it is not her boat that is waiting offshore . As the audience process this , they are then hit with fearfulness and heartbreak when it becomes clear that these are Charlie ’s final moments on the show . His heroic death overpowers the repose of the picture , but his final message to Desmond hammer home the foreboding threat .
The flash bulb - forward reveal is a game - changing moment in the show as it introduces something whole new to the data format of the show and bug a big storyline to come . However , " Not Penny ’s gravy boat " visualize a more imminent threat entering the story while also removing one of the most darling characters onLost . While very dissimilar moments , both help to cement themselves as truly iconic moments in the series that elevateLostto new levels .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
lose is a mystery dramatic play serial make for telecasting that follows a radical of survivors of a plane crash and say its tale between the past tense , present , and future via flashbacks . When Oceanic Airlines Flight 815 crashes and lands on a mysterious island in the pacific ocean , the castaways discover their new temporary home may have a judgment of its own , as strange supernatural issue keep them locked to the island . From an unknown dark fastball creature to dangerous islanders , the passenger must work together to outlast the island ’s seemingly deadly intention .
