How I Met Your Mother
Summary
There are n’t many series finales that divided fans as much asHow I Met Your Motherdid . The serial followed a group of friends living in New York border around one of them recite the level to his children of how he met their mother . While the focus of the show was really the friendship between the chief type , the show was always leading up to him meet " the female parent , " but the finale unveil he still harbored feelings for one of his friends years later .
There were several pick that mass had subject with , but the major one was the fact that Robin ( Cobie Smulders ) ended up with Ted ( Josh Radnor ) in the remnant . Some spectator would ’ve preferred her to stay with Barney ( Neil Patrick Harris ) , whom she married in the instalment before the two - part finish . Fans of both relationships have fair reasons for why they believe their duo should have end up together , and in the instance of such a long - running show , there ’s flock of evidence to argue for both match .
How I Met Your Mother was a systematically great sitcom in its early days . Though later seasons did n’t match up , it always had memorable moments .
Why Robin Should Have Ended Up With Barney
The Last Season Would Have Meant More
It ’s unbelievably rare for a television show time of year to take place over the path of only a few day . Shows that make that timeline choice , like24 , tend to have it built into the plan for the show from the kickoff . Aside from some flashback and flashgun - forwards , all ofHow I Met Your Mother’sfinal time of year , amazingly , took place during Barney and Robin ’s wedding weekend , with deal of episodes center on the couple and those cheeseparing to them . While this meant the time of year had many makeweight sequence , it did make the wedding feel monumental when it came .
Unfortunately , this was all unmake during the first part of the close , when the couple chop-chop got divorced . This made the time of year ’s Charles Frederick Worth of build - up feel like a waste of fourth dimension . Had Barney and Robin stayed together , time of year 9 might have been treasure more as a whole .
More Believable That They’d Stay Together
One of the problems with Ted ’s final romantic gesture in the show ’s finale — besides the fact that theone tantrum ruined a well - written character — is that he ’d made move like that for Robin many meter before , and the two of them never lasted as a duad . In fact , Robin tend to balk at his grand gestures . HIMYM’saudience was given no reason to consider that suddenly they ’d be a staring match , just because they were older and Ted already had kids .
While Ted and Robin had elect to remain friend and completely push aside their amatory difficulties , Barney and Robin had not
On the other hand , Barney and Robin had already worked through many of their difficulty as a couple together . While Ted and Robin had elected to remain friend and completely ignored their amatory difficulties , Barney and Robin had not , If their sudden divorcement in the finale had n’t happen , it would be much more credible that they could stay together eternally .
Custom image by Amanda Bruce
The Mother Could Have Lived
Tracy ’s agile expiry in the series close made it one ofHow I Met Your Mother’ssaddest episode , and anger a important telephone number of fans . Despite only featuring in the final time of year ( aside from one snap in season 8) , the character was super likable , so much so that viewers could n’t accept her being killed off to provide Ted and Robin to be together .
to boot , viewers had hold off year for Ted to meet the female parent , so after all of that build - up , they want and expect a felicitous ending for the couple . Fans felt rip off by the perceive twist of hersuddenly being taken from them without getting to pass much time watch Tracy and Ted together . Had Robin end up with Barney , the mother could ’ve lived , securing a felicitous hereafter for all of the role involve .
Barney’s Number One
Barney was with a flock of women throughout the series , although his onlyserious relationships were with Quinn , Nora , and Robin . He did n’t trust Quinn enough to espouse her , and he hold up Nora because he chose Robin instead . ( At the sentence , Robin had n’t been quick to prefer him , but eventually , they found their way back to one another . )
Barney loved Robin more than anyone else , and if she ’d end up with him , she ’d have been with someone who viewed her as his first choice , which would be a heartwarming end to the show . In the actual finale , it terminate up feel like Ted only went back to Robin because his true lovemaking , Tracy , had passed away . It made Robin seem like a solace prize following his loss , and it did n’t finger like Robin had bring in the first place in Ted ’s heart .
How I Met Your Mother buff were so vocal about their hate of the conclusion that the show release an alternative version … what did they alter ?
How I Met Your Mother is a television series that follows a father telling his children about his past. Released in 2005, it explores his experiences and adventures with four close friends, leading up to meeting their mother, as depicted through a series of flashbacks.
Better Ending For Barney
No matterthe arguments fans have about him , everyone can agree that Barney ’s luck inHow I Met Your Motherwas a strange one . After his marriage to Robin end , he retrograde back into being a womanizer , before by chance getting one of his dalliances pregnant . The import he shared with his child after her birth was an emotional one , but the whole storyline felt impel and rushed . Barney grew significantly as a person when he was with Robin , and the sodding end to his graphic symbol spark would have been toend up with the cleaning woman who serve him to grow .
It can be argue that Robin helping Barney to grow set him to be an grownup for his new child , but the increase he experienced with Robin prepared him to be an equal spouse , not a Father of the Church . It seemed like a unknown choice to end his most important relationship in the series just as he bring out he had a child .
Why Robin Ending Up With Ted Was The Right Choice
A Point To The Story
Once Ted finally cease telling his kids the fib of how he met their female parent , his daughter Penny deduced that the real reason he told them the narration was to get their blessing to day of the month Robin . Without Ted bid to pursue her again , the only point to the account would ’ve been to explain how he ’d met Tracy , and that would n’t have made much sense since , as Penny pointed out , Tracy was barely in the account at all .
This revelation does help to make the meandering tale that focus on Ted ’s kinship with his acquaintance , instead of the mother of his children , seem deserving it . If , years after living separate lives and aggrieve the loss of his wife , he still has feelings for Robin , it makes signified for the end of his story to have his kids understand how much he cares for her .
The Better Couple
While Ted and Robin always struggled as a twosome , they were arguably good together than she and Barney were . Robin ’s human relationship with Ted was the sweeter of the two , as it did n’t have the incessant screaming mates nor the manipulation that the formerly married couple had . Ted proved on several occasions that he do it more about Robin than Barney did ; he even teach a class on her . Robin could ’ve been happy with either man , but she ’d likely have a more pleasurable and focus - free life with Ted .
There would never have been the threat of Ted attempting to manipulate her into something she did n’t require , and she , in turn , would n’t do the same to Ted . Though there were bumps in their human relationship , and differences between the two , certainly , they were n’t as drastic as those between Robin and Barney .
It Was Surprising
Few on - again , off - again kinship in television set have keep lover guessing as much as Ted and Robin ’s did during the ravel of the show . This is because watcher knew from the first sequence that Ted would finally meet the mother and have Kyd with her and he cite " Aunt Robin " while telling his story to his kids . Plus , Robin ’s own on - and - off relationship with Barney also hold out throughout most of the series .
A lot of the predictability that usually comes withwill - they - won’t - they couples was n’t there for Ted and Robin . This continued into the final season , and though many suspected the mother ’s decease , it seemed Barney and Robin were together for the long haul . Thus , Ted ending up with Robin instead was a genuine surprisal , even though some devotee of the show felt thatshe deserved a better ending .
Created Several Dramatic Moments In The Finale
For Ted and Robin to end up together , several dramatic moments had to occur in the finis , including a divorcement , the mother ’s death , and a big romantic gesture at the end . These not only offer surprising add-on to the plot that the consultation could n’t well see coming , but they also offered callbacks to the very start of the show when Robin and Ted first diddle with the idea of being a pair .
The wedding could have been moved to the finis
It would ’ve been severe for the show to make here and now of significanceif Robin ended up with Barney instead , as near everything would have been settled by the last episode . The nuptials could have been moved to the finale , but that would mean adding yet another makeweight instalment before it . Instead , the many revelation of the finale mean it was an unexpected experience .
It Was Always Ted And Robin
While the serial might have been couch as a story about Ted meeting the mother of his tyke , How I Met Your Motherwas really about Ted and Robin , as she was the woman he saw and immediately strike down for in the pilot episode . Their on - and - off human relationship was a major facet of the show throughout its nine time of year , whereas Robin ’s join with Barney truly only amount by and by .
make this , it would have been strange to disregard the Ted and Robin relationship in the sitcom ’s last episode . Ted and Robin ending up together illustrated what the show had really been about for its nine - twelvemonth run . It brought the show full circle . The spark between the two in the very first episode were found again , correctly down to their interactions with Robin poking her chief out her window to see him in the coda .
Why Robin Should Have Ended The Series Single
Not Every Sitcom Needs To Pair Off The Main Cast
There is a tendency in sitcoms about 30 - somethings to treat entering into a relationship , getting married , and have youngster as the principal goal . While that is the idea of ahappily - ever - after for a batch of people in the real humans , it is n’t for everyone , and sitcoms should really become more reflective of that .
Friendsis an early representative of a series that set about to pair off all six of its principal cast , but that ’s not what happen in the goal . While Ross and Rachel finish up back together and Chandler and Monica were in a loving relationship with new children , Phoebe was with someone outside the friend radical and Joey ended the series single . Having a character of the primary friend grouping end the series single is more in line with realness , and Robin could have been that character forHow I Met Your female parent .
Robin’s Career Was Her Focus
It ’s made clear from the start of the show thatHow I Met Your Motheris going to tell the story in the title . Ted ’s journey to find the female parent of his kids is the master plot line , but along the direction , he tells his kids about his friendships with Barney , Marshall , Lilly , and Robin . He sing about Lilly and Marshall hitting bumps in their marriage and working them out , about Barney growing up , and about Robin reach her calling aspiration .
Robin ’s electric arc is really about her career . Yes , she has romantic relationship in the show ( principally , with both Ted and Barney ) , but her story is one of an sovereign charwoman who is n’t necessarily concerned in everyone else ’s idea of a happily - ever - after . She want to find satisfaction in her career . Her arc does n’t have to end with a income tax return to Ted or Barney .
Both Relationships Didn’t Work Out For Valid Reasons
Robin had relationships with both Barney and Ted during the long run of the show . Both relationship did n’t work out for very valid grounds , and it would have been just fine for the show ’s writers to go for those reasons and allow Robin to move on .
Robing and Barney , for model , institute out some of the worst trait in one another . They manipulate one another and team up up to cook others . They even cheat on their significant others with one another before Robin decides she does n’t want to go back to Barney . Though they have sport together , they ’re ultimately poorly - suited to a lasting relationship .
Ted , on the other hand , is more in making love with who he believe Robin is than who she actually is . That is the crux of the matter of the problems in their family relationship . Ted believes that he ’s found the pure woman at the start of the show , only to find that the more he stimulate to know Robin , the less that is true for him . That ’s one of the intellect they do n’t work out out , and it would have made more sense for the two of them to continue friends in the end ofHow I Met Your Mother .
Your Rating
Your gossip has not been saved
Cast
How I Met Your Mother is a television serial that follow a father telling his fry about his past tense . Released in 2005 , it explores his experiences and adventures with four secretive Friend , run up to match their mother , as depicted through a series of flashback .
