The Boys
The finale ofThe Boysseason 2 included the show ’s scandalous Becca Butcher death — but how Becca Butcher dies was predetermined by one of her early decisions . Now thatThe Boysseason 3 has come and gone , there ’s no better prison term to look back at one of the show ’s most polar second . flirt by Shantel VanSanten , Becca was revealed to be alive inThe Boysseason 1 finale . Having successfully hold birth to Homelander ’s son , she had check to raise him in secretive privacy and allow Butcher to think she was dead . Homelander tried to modeling Ryan , and oftentimes drive Becca ’s Word to tap into his latent superpowers , but only when she was in danger did Ryan ’s powers certify . When Becca was attacked by Stormfront , his optical maser vision severed Stormfront ’s limb and burned her alive . unhappily , Becca was also arrest in the crossfire , result in the death of Butcher ’s wife simple month after he find her again .
On the surface , it ’s clear that Ryan , incited byHomelander and Stormfront , was by chance responsible for Becca Butcher ’s death . However , looking deeper , Butcher ’s wife herself was equally an architect in her own demise . Knowing all too well the upbringing Homelander experience ( and the world he became as a resultant role ) , Becca adjudicate to raise Ryan in completely the opposite fashion . Where Homelander was nurture in a lab to become a weapon , Becca obliterate Ryan ’s powers from him to make a loving surroundings . Even after Ryan memorise he might potentially have abilities , Becca was deeply averse to him learning to engage them . Unfortunately , that decision would go on to be the difference between life and destruction . Had Ryan been taught to perfect his powers during the stable , worry childhood his mom provide , he would ’ve had the self - control condition to killthe Nazi paladin Stormfrontwithout causing Becca Butcher ’s last .
relate : The Boys Season 2 Ending Explained ( In Detail )
Becca Butcher’s Season 2 Death Did Her Justice
It ’s understandable that Becca might have had some awe of the likely effect . As implied by the overall plan for Ryan , though , there was always going to be a meter he learned the full truth and had to embrace his heritage . Becca could ’ve claim that inevitable eventuality into her own hands and helped Ryan both control his ability and hold back his good centre . That would ’ve made even more sense after Homelander started showing up , constitute something of a defensive strategy . By that power point in Ryan ’s life , Becca was dead sure that he would grow up to be good . She prove that with herlast words to Billy Butcherin the finale . If Becca ’s faith had been able to override those fears , she might have survived to guide Ryan through the next chapters of his lifespan . Sadly , as proven by the Becca Butcher decease prospect , it was n’t meant to be .
Rather than a ailment , however , it really served as a will to the top - notch plotting inThe Boysseason 2 — and serve to make the moment Butcher ’s married woman died more poignant . Showrunner Eric Kripke antecedently state that the show would go deeper rather than big . That proved just as on-key for characters like Becca as it did the member of the titulary group andthe superheroes of Vought International . Rather than make Becca a bystander or ineffectual dupe of the tarradiddle , Becca was grant more agency and had a hand in how Becca Butcher dies . Unfortunately , it was tragically realized . Becca was condemn as much by her own ( graspable ) emotion and determination as she was by the external forces that plagued her and created the situation . As such , the Butcher ’s wife destruction scene onThe Boyswas grant extra nuance and an element of tragically dramatic sarcasm .
How Becca Butcher Died In The Comics
How Becca Butcher go inThe Boysmay have been part her fault , but at least she had some eccentric of office on the show . Her demise in the comic , however , is much more gruesome and borders on offensive . Becca was give hardly any autonomy throughout the comic , and her character was greatly better in this respect forThe Boysshow . Becca Butcher ’s comic book opposite number ’s demisewas violently needless and would be considered an insult to Shantel VanSanten ’s version of the character reference .
In Garth Ennis ' in writing novel , Becca does n’t hold Homelander ’s baby to full - condition , nor does she disappear after she is raped . rather , she attempts to move on and live a normal life story with Billy after the fact . In aTwilight - type winding , the fetus grows at a speedy charge per unit , being almost full - term at 3 months . The fetus then claws its way out of Becca while she and Billy are in bed . Billy learn of the rape , though he has no clue which of the Seven did it . The foetus give matricide by literally tearing its way through Becca ’s stomach before turning on Billy .
Related : How The Boys Can adjust The Comics Ending
The foetus - Supe tries to use its laser eyesto put Billy down once and for all , until Butcher puts it out of its wretchedness with the wrong remnant of a lamp shade . The verbal description of these events is horrify enough , butThe Boyscomic shows every moment in graphical contingent , let in when the lampshade busts open up the fetus ' skull . Ennis does n’t shy away from the gore factor with Becca ’s gruesome death , and while it ’s supposed to show how dire the world of Supes is , the picture ultimately come across as a cruel and meaningless plot item . Ennis ' characterization of how Becca Butcher dies is disgraceful , even forThe Boys . Thankfully , her death was manage much better on the show .
Next : The Boys Season 4 ’s New Supes : Who Are Firecracker & Sister Sage ?
