Related
If there is one eccentric for whom sports fan feel extremely bad when it number to theHarry Potterseries , it ’s Sirius Black . Sirius is a character who ’s portrayed to be a murdering convict , broken free of Azkaban to assault and stamp out his godson . The opinions shift middling quickly when it ’s bring out he was framed all those years ago and has serve twelve year in prison for fundamentally nothing .
But Sirius is n’t all innocent , and he ’s had some pretty problematic moments , too . Although there have been many times fans have felt absolutely dread for the vulture , there have also been times where he ’s been a shade hateable .
update on December 10th , 2021 by Tanner Fox : Is Sirius Black evil ? Is Sirius fatal good ? It ’s one of the most intriguing mystery story in the Harry Potter series . The character gave fans heap of reasons to both get it on and hate him , making for one compelling character .
Times We Felt Bad For Sirius Black
Finding Out He Had His Likeness Burned From The Black Family Tree
It ’s no secret that Sirius Black intensely dislike his class . His blood whiteness - haunt elders and wicked cousin were detestable , to be certain , but grow up as an pariah is n’t easy for anyone . Outsiders likewise , that ’s a major grounds why Sirius and Harry bonded so easily .
That tell , while his family was atrocious , returning home to see his visage burned from the family tree diagram must have taken an emotional bell . Regardless of the familial rift , being utterly disinherit by one ’s parents ca n’t be easy .
When He Was In Azkaban
Upon incur out Sirius Black spend 12 year in Azkaban for a crime he did not commit , it ’s hard not to feel terrible for him . Azkaban is not a normal prison house or pleasant place . It ’s flanked by dementors , which mean that anyone who ride out there will have the felicity and energy sapped out of them .
Sirius populate 12 year without knowing how to be happy , clinging to his insanity only because he knew was innocent . That ’s no life for anyone , let alone someone who did nothing improper .
Finding Out He’s An Unregistered Animagus
Sirius Black and his booster originally choose to become animagi to support Lupin , who was fight with his lycanthropy . in all likelihood in keeping with his name , Sirius adopted the form of a Canis familiaris , but his position as an unregistered animagus would n’t help his already troubled simulacrum .
A known troublemaker , his eerie animal visage and unregistered status more or less brand him as a criminal . It ’s a ruth , as , beneath the terrible outside is a genuinely genial - hearted person , but those who ’ve seen his brute form may find him hard to confide .
Hearing About His Escape
When Sirius Black describes how and why he ’s fly the coop , it ’s pretty terrible to read . He swim all the way to shore and is pretty much skin and bone for weeks as he attempts to find food and survive . His need is actually the opposition of what everyone thinks .
Rather than attempting to bolt down Harry , he ’s actually seek to lay aside him . turn over he must have been very imperfect , the fact he swim back to shore because he needed to save Harry is passably astonishing .
Learning About His Family
Sirius Black tells Harry about his family while in Grimmauld Place , and it ’s a grim taradiddle . It ’s coupled with fit a portrait of Walburga Black , who yell at Sirius repeatedly .
Sirius articulate he ran away when he was a teen , and , although he does n’t go into much item about his puerility or home life , it ’s heavily imply he was miss and abused for the fact that he chose not to postulate himself in stark - profligate mania and biases .
When He’s Locked In His Family’s House
InOrder of the Phoenix , Dumbledore forces Sirius Black to stay in spite of appearance , and Sirius find dead useless . To make thing worse , he ’s ensnare in a house that understandably has no happy memories for him . He finally leaves even though he ’s severalize not to , and fans were torn .
On one hired hand , it must have been atrocious for Sirius to spend so much time trap in a place he hated , in particular after escape confinement in an equally detestable prison house . On the other , he disobey an order from Dumbledore in a important flow before the second Wizarding War , which could have been disastrous .
When He Died
Sirius Black is killed byBellatrix Lestrange , his own cousin , after fall to Harry ’s delivery , knocked backward into a velum that it ’s implied lead-in to the hereafter . bump off by the very family he choose to leave , killed after only a short time out of Azkaban , it ’s devastating that he dies this path .
This is also a brutal second for Harry , as he ’s made to deal with the loss of the closest affair he had to a kinfolk ever since that disastrous encounter with Lord Voldemort year ago .
Times We Hated Sirius Black
Seeing His Shabby Appearance
Potterheads sure enough wo n’t hate Sirius Black for his appearance ; after pass years in one of the wizarding world ’s most infamous prison house , that just would n’t be fair . Yet , sacrifice his utterly ragged coming into court throughout most ofThe Prisoner of Azkaban , it ’s not hard to understand why some in the wizarding community would hate him .
weary and disheveled in both his human and animagus form , Sirius certainly does n’t make a great first impression . Part of the hate for him likely stems from his coverage in The Daily Prophet , but , tattooed and shattered , he lives up to his infamy at first coup d’oeil .
When He Broke Into The Common Room
In the book , there ’s a scene that read place before readers know he ’s innocent where pitch-dark tears into the Gryffindor Common Room with a knife . It ’s presumed that he ’s look for Harry and that he is endangering other student in his quest to discover and kill his godson .
It lay the whole school on boundary , and , as no one knows on the button how he break in , it ’s a slenderly terrifying moment . He seems like the substantial villain of the ledger ; after all , why else would he die in with a weapon ?
Learning About His Treatment Of Kreacher
The Black family ’s firm house - elf , Kreacher never saw eye to eye with Sirius . Kreacher was obsessed with his villainous masters and bought into their infatuation with wizarding profligate whiteness . Sirius , on the other handwriting , rejected his family and their interests .
Kreacher was never the most sympathetic sort , and he eventually play a role in Sirius ' death . However , rather than hatred and vitriol , Sirius should have pitied the house - elf . An indentured handmaid with no way to take shape or express opinion of his own , Sirius Black may have done well to distinguish that Kreacher was nothing but a product of his short environment .
Seeing Him Bully Snape
A flashback shows that both James Potter andSirius Black were extremely fell towards Severus Snape in their Hogwarts years . While Snape is far from a pleasant someone , the way James and Sirius treated him is utterly callous .
They humiliated him in front of fellow students , and the ledger even recount of a clock time that Sirius tried to kill him by leading him into Remus ' path on a full moon . How Remus ever forgive him for this …
His Sniping At Harry
Sometimes , it seems as if Sirius Black just ca n’t behave like an grownup . Perhaps a life spend either in prison or on the run was n’t contributory to his worked up maturation .
When Harry is trying to keep him safe by refusing to foregather up with him and have him running around in the open since he is still a need criminal , Sirius almost make playfulness of him in the books and is cold towards him for week . All because Harry really require to keep him safe .
Every Time He Risked His Life
Sirius Black often unnecessarily risks his life , and rooter pay off angry with him because Harry demand him . He insist on accompanying Harry to the wagon train place while disguised in frankfurter form — and does n’t conduct much like a dog , giving himself to Lucius Malfoy — and other excursions because he ’s uneasy .
It might be understandable , but it ’s hard not to like he had more compliments for his own life .
When He Called Harry ‘James’
Sirius Black calls Harry ' James ' by chance event in the heat of the moment , and , although it ’s sad , it ’s a sign that he is n’t being what Harry postulate .
Molly Weasley was correct ; he thinks of Harry as a better friend more than a son , and he ca n’t really provide what Harry needs in a paternal bod . It ’s tragic , but Sirius should have done a better chore of concealing his emotions .
NEXT:10 Reasons Why Harry Potter ’s Sirius & Lupin Are n’t Real protagonist
