Related
With a vast number of animated movies in the studio ’s history , Disneyhas made a move towards producing live - action remakes of its fan - preferent stories in recent years . This trend has broadly been meet with mixed responses , both critically and by full audiences , but the endeavor continues nevertheless .
While some of these remakes were unneeded , there are some inspire films — whether they be works from Disney or another production company — that could gain from the alive - action remake treatment .
Updated on December 12th, 2022 by Stacie Rook:
With approaching live - action moviesThe Little MermaidandSnow White , Disney has indicate that it does n’t specify to stop making remaking of earlier quicken study anytime soon . Even so , some animise works make out better than others as a unrecorded - activity story .
Animated Films Where Remakes Weren’t Needed
The Lion King (1994) - The Lion King (2019)
The success of Disney ’s 1994The Lion Kingmade it the complete candidate for a live - action adaption , but ultimately , its 2019 remake brought nothing significantly new to the write up of Simba and the animals of Pride Rock .
The Jungle Book (1967) - The Jungle Book (2016)
A hybrid of lively - action at law and CGI , 2016’sThe Jungle Bookis an impressive feat to behold , and it ’s this curiosity which led to the deed of conveyance gain Best Visual Effects at the Academy Awards in 2017 .
While the live - action adaptation does introduce some new constituent to the account , it ’s also very similar to Disney ’s 1967 work , which sometimes make the motion picture ’s quality experience jarring . Additionally , 2016’sThe Jungle Bookis not a melodious , which rifle it of perhaps the most memorable aspect of the animated film on which it ’s establish . It ’s these element compound which make the remaking feel unneeded .
Dumbo (1941) - Dumbo (2019)
Tim Burton ’s 2019 adaptation ofDumboalmost instantly stray from the animated flick ’s game , and its important story changes made it chop-chop lose the spirit and emotional weighting of the original film .
Alice in Wonderland (1951) - Alice in Wonderland (2010)
Disney ’s creepy originalAlice in Wonderlandfrom 1951 perfectly adapted the surrealism of Lewis Carroll ’s Bible , capturing the nuances of every character and lending a sense of marvel and unsettling beauty to each location Alice move through .
The 2010Alice in Wonderland , which kicked off Disney ’s chain of resilient - military action remaking , was also visually striking , but had a far black colour palette , gazump it of the psychedelic smell that ’s often associated with Wonderland . Additionally , its account made Alice into more of a lower-ranking character , favour figures like the Hatter and the Red Queen , which seems like a miss opportunity for one of Disney ’s most recognizable heroine .
Pinocchio (1940) - Pinocchio (2022)
Disney’sworst - reviewed live - military action remaketo date , 2022’sPinocchiowas panned by critics for its lacklustre magic , and failure to land anything new to the old tale , though some of the voice acting received praise .
view all unneeded , the 2022Pinocchiofeels particularly soulless not only when equate to the 1940 Disney version , but also the acclaimedGuillermo del Toro ’s Pinocchio , which was also released in 2022 and surrender on a alone interpretation of the fairy tale .
Animated Films That Could Have Great Live Action Remakes
Ice Age (2002)
While the firstIce Agemovie from Blue Sky Studios is a great comedy full of laughable characters , its animation is not the strongest , an yield that only becomes more patent as time goes by . This is specially unmistakable in the motion-picture show ’s for the most part white landscape , which does n’t do its epic mise en scene justice .
Although seeing Manny , Sid , and Diego in their ‘ live - natural action ’ form would trust on the same CGI that has lead remaking likeThe Lion Kingto receive mixed response , the prospect of seeing the rarified , polar world the character exist in — alongside some dinosaur — makes a remake seem deserving it , and it has the potential to be a optical fete perfect for the film theatre blind .
Bolt (2008)
Even though Disney’sBoltwas well - received critically , it has n’t become iconic in the same way that many other Disney animate movies have . Even so , Bolthas an interesting plot line , and feature a mix of human and animal fibre that would translate well to a lively - activeness remaking .
The Iron Giant (1999)
From Warner Bros. ,The Iron Giantis a unique movie have one ofthe best non - Disney animated robots . Its life style and fictional character have made it a cult classic , alongside its truly devout storyline , and a strangely warm voiceover from Vin Diesel in the titulary role .
In a way , the picture show could gain from being left alone , with no sequels or adaptation to interfere with its bequest . At the same time , though , the Iron Giant is an iconic character , and a compounding of the movie ’s real - world setting and largely human cast could translate well for a live - activity remaking .
Tangled (2010)
As several animated Disney princess movies have already spawned live - action remaking — like 2015’sCinderellaand 2017’sBeauty and the Beast — it seems potential that Rapunzel fromTangledcould also star in a live - activity remake in the studio ’s hereafter .
With a layered personality and strong character arc that realize her one ofthe unspoilt Disney princesses , Rapunzel ’s story could provide plenty of material for further adjustment . to boot , Rapunzel ’s relationships with both Flynn Rider and Mother Gothel are complex , and could be enchanced through bouncy - activity exploration .
Ratatouille (2007)
Pixar’sRatatouilleis unique for the studio because a large percentage of its principal case are human , and it ’s this very vista of the movie that makes it a great pick for a live - action remaking .
Though the so-and-so Remy is one of the film ’s agonist , and some of his family and protagonist have in the report as well , he spends much of the film hiding from detection under Linguini ’s hat , a fact which could make live - natural action adaptation easier . A dear news report with lots of eye , Ratatouillecould profit from the nuance of live - activity performance .
NEXT:15 Disney / Pixar Movies That merit More tending , According To Reddit
