Related
In 1998,Disney ChannelairedHalloweentown , which would finally become a craze classic and ongoing dealership . Three follow - up films come afterward , and for years since , audiences have been becharm by witches , warlocks , troll , and the noesis that " Being normal is vastly overrated . " The first picture introduced the gist graphic symbol and Halloweentown ’s magical world while also revealing that the Piper family were enchantress and warlocks .
The picture that take after the original added to the already existing capacity , include more rules and secrets about the townsfolk ’s mystical past . But , not everything about the enfranchisement made gumption . Years afterReturn To Halloweentownaired , there are still questions or thing that feel undecided about the popular series , whether it be details that break continuity or the reduction of a character ’s role ; not every part of the enfranchisement made sense .
Updated on October 7, 2022, by Lynn Gibbs:
With Halloween around the corner , there ’s nothing better than engorge one of the Disney Channel ’s best vacation franchises , Halloweentown . Fans agree that the first and 2nd movie were some of the best , while movies three and four go down . Questions like " does Marnie have power in Halloweentown ? Or why was Sophie barely inHalloweentown High ? " are continuously ask while rewatching . This lead to modest observations that were missed when viewers were younger and no longer make signified as adults . Nevertheless , Halloweentownis one of those craze classics that ’s rewatched every drop .
Halloweentown’s Time Difference Between Worlds
Aggie tells Marnie , Dylan , and Sophie that two hours in the deadly earth can be the eq of two Day or weeks in Halloweentown . That principle justifies that the minor could bide and aid Aggie defeat the darkness and get home before midnight in the mortal world . But , outside Halloweentown , that convention does n’t hold up . In the sequel , time seems to be the same in the two worlds as Kal ’s spell takes over .
It also force questions about if Halloweentown had existed for a millenary inReturn To Halloweentown , had it been a thousand years for the mortal world as well ? Aggie had supposedly been over 1,000 years old and lived in one house for 200 years . It would be unpopular to go against Aggie ’s logic , but some things just do n’t add together up .
Sophie’s Reduced Screen Time Was A Low Blow To Her Character
InHalloweentownandHalloweentown II : Kalabar ’s Revenge , Sophie has an intuition that permit her to know that bad thing are occurring . She is an constitutional part of the Cromwell kinsfolk and has a natural ability to do thaumaturgy , until the third film .
Sophie ’s role is drastically tighten inHalloweentown Highto the point where she is less essential than a supporting case . Sophie does n’t hold any significance to the plot and seems to be there to cue fans she exists . Sophie ’s most significant power to detect if something is haywire appears to have gone away . When the Cromwell enchantress miss their conjuring trick , Sophie is n’t even present . InReturn to Halloweentown , Sophie is mentioned to be traveling with Aggie but never appears . Halloweentownis one of theDisney Channel ’s secure Halloween movie , but it still has noticeable flaws like this .
Dylan’s Magic Was Brushed Under The Rug
Like Sophie , Dylan ’s role got recede in translation . Dylan exhibit his first signs of magic in the final moments ofHalloweentown . Although Dylan never loved to do magic like his siblings , the continuation is aware that Dylan has power too , and he uses magic to help his kin open up a hepatic portal vein after midnight on Halloween .
InReturn To Halloweentown , Dylan reveals that he does n’t use magic for anything other than f number reading , once again acknowledging Dylan ’s powers . But , Halloweentown Hightreats Dylan as if he ’s mortal . Dylan ca n’t get himself down from the cap , and when Marnie and Aggie lose their business leader , Dylan does n’t .
Aggie’s Reduced Role Was A Mistake
One of the thing thatfans did n’t get laid aboutReturn To Halloweentownwas that Disney made several controversial decisions , and one of them was subdue Aggie Cromwell ’s role . She is mean to be working on interdimensional time locomotion with Sophie .
lover of the previous three films have intercourse Aggie to be a vital part of the fib . But , Return To Halloweentownmakes the fault of drop a line Aggie out of the flick , only having her appear just long enough to reveal Marnie ’s college plans and give a vague tip about a mysterious yesteryear . Aggie ’s legacy and history bind a vital part of the picture show , but it does n’t make sense to take out one of the franchise ’s most significant characters .
Aggie’s Backstory
Halloweentownisn’t the chilling Disney Channel Halloween picture , but it did have a complex backstory that fans liked . Aggie has referenced the sinister days of Halloweentown before and that there had been conflicts with someone . Aggie is an influential part of Halloweentown , but her backstory sum up into the last film seemed as if it survive to try and explain Aggie ’s influence , give Marnie a destiny , and describe why the Cromwells were so powerful .
Gwen supposedly knew nothing of her female parent ’s past tense , but if witches can live a prospicient sprightliness in Halloweentown , and Gwen grew up there , it does n’t make gumption that Gwen would n’t know her mother ’s history .
Gwen’s Continuity
Gwen opposes witching inHalloweentown , and although she never gave up her powers , she never uses them . Gwen decided to foreswear her menage ’s chronicle and bring up her small fry as mortals . Her design backfire after the kids learn the truth about illusion . By the end of the first film , Gwen appears to let go of her hatred of magic , resolve to train Marnie . Gwen did n’t havethe strongest powers inHalloweentown , but fans would n’t know because she was reluctant to use them .
By the 2d movie , Gwen is back to hate magic . She views it as the foeman , and while Gwen is n’t against her child using it all the time , there is a feeling of resentment . In some ways , it ’s as if her growth at the remainder ofHalloweentownnever happen . However , in the last two flick , Gwen has move on from hating conjuring trick , using it herself to dilate their business firm and as if by magic bring grocery to her at the memory .
Recasting Marnie Was A Huge Mistake
For those who had loved theHalloweentownmovies , they had a prominent surprisal come whenReturn To Halloweentownpremiered . or else of Kimberly J. Brown , the dear main theatrical role Marnie had been replaced by Sara Paxton . Fans of the serial publication agreed that the maincharacter should have never been recast .
The selection to remould the main character in the last movie of the serial publication does n’t make any sense . Return To Halloweentownis not look at as a fan - favorite of the serial . Between recasting Marnie , reducing Aggie ’s role , remove Sophie , and creating an entirely different whole step , the final celluloid did not have the same feel as the three before it .
What Happened After Halloweentown High?
One of the most massive here and now ofHalloweentown Highshows mortals discovering that illusion , witches , warlock , and other creatures are real . bonk that humans have changed prove Marnie ’s contention that the portal could remain for good open rather than close . InReturn To Halloweentown , Ethan fills in some space , explaining that many in Halloweentown went to college in the deathly humanity , which was why Witch University open up itself to non - witch students .
But , they never show how the individual handled such a reveal . Marnie continued to go to schoolhouse with her classmates , knowing she was a witch , but they never show what happened next .
Marnie’s Parents Introduction Doesn’t Add Up
Marnie mentions that her mum and dad meet on Halloween . by and by , Aggie say that the portal connect the deadly and magical worlds only appears on Halloween . But , since Gwen ’s backstory is not full flesh out , there are some question regarding how Gwen chose to stay in the deadly world .
She had gone to a Halloween political party and come across her husband , but since she could not render home on any other night , what did Gwen do ? Did she reunify with the man the following yr ? Did she decide to stay in the deadly humanity from that dark on ? Gwen elucidate that she prefer the deathly world , but the films never give a firm backstory into her reasons to remain there .
What Happened To Kal?
The final moments ofHalloweentown II : Kalabar ’s Revengemakes a expectant deal about Kal . He does n’t die at the end of the movie and escapes instead . Luke bring up that Kal would be back , and Marnie say they would be quick when he reelect . But , Kal never comes back and is never mentioned again .
For a scoundrel intend to be such a major threat , it does n’t make sense that he never comes back or dally any function again . Even if the moving-picture show did n’t need Kal to return to the franchise , his taradiddle is leave unresolved . But his plan also did n’t make sense . His father had want to give the mortal world back to the creatures of Halloweentown , but Kal ’s architectural plan does n’t even do that . Instead , he wanted to ferment humans into monsters and monsters into human beings , but that does n’t appear to benefit anyone .
NEXT:10 Forgotten Disney Channel Original Movies Worth Re - Watching
